12 Treasured Family Desserts Shared By Our Readers

The only thing sweeter than this pie is the heart-melting story that reader Cassie Tidwell Tramel shared about her beloved grandmother. Grab a Kleenex before you click.

Shared with us by reader Susan Sartory from Juno Beach, Florida, this old-school cake cooks low and slow for the best evenly cooked texture.

These crackly, ginger-spiced cookies shared with us by North Carolina reader Kristin Stewart warmed our hearts with their sweet name and cozy, nostalgic flavor.

This “neighborhood cake” submitted by reader Mary Vail-Grube from Allen, Texas, wowed our editors and tasters. It’s like eating the best slice of homemade banana bread, but slathered with caramel frosting. Why didn’t we think of this sooner?

Reader Beverly Thompson of Willis, Texas, lost her mom Neddy a few years back, but celebrates her memory with this precious pie. “I love her little recipe card because it’s in her handwriting,” Beverly says.

Tennessee reader Connie Taylor loved this harvest-hued cake when she was a child, and notes that her mother had two versions: one for company that had a crown of cream cheese frosting, and one for family, that got by with simple dusting of powdered sugar.

Beth Lewis of Cary, North Carolina, remembers her mother making this pie every Thanksgiving for her grandsons. Beth has continued the tradition, sending the boys home with pies that often get eaten on the car ride home.

This humble cake was born during the Great Depression, when times were tough and ingredients got stretched a long way. But don’t let that fool you—this dessert is delicious. Reader Pat Ynesta from Navarre, Florida, remembers her mom baking this cake in her favorite pan. “It was handed down from our grandma to her and now me,” Pat remembers. “It’s probably almost 100 yers old.”

Texas reader Barbara Pachman treasures her mother’s cake for the memory and the flavor; we love the shortcuts of cake and pudding mixes that make it so easy. The amaretto doesn’t hurt, either.

Don’t adjust your dial—those are indeed potato chips the cookies! Reader Ruth Maicki from Tampa Bay, Florida, says these were her mom’s most-requested desserts. We love the salty crunch the chips bring to these sweet, thin cookies.

Reader Meghan Mays is sneaky! She got the recipe for her husband’s favorite cake that his grandmother used to make, and surprised him with it at Thanksgiving. Needless to say, she earned some big brownie points!

Reader Vicki Casey from Huntersville, North Carolina, shared this lovely recipe created by her thrifty mother-in-law that uses the juice leftover from canned pineapple to make a beautiful pie. It’s like lemon meringue with a tropical twist.