No trip to Costco truly feels complete without a stop at the food court. Just like the warehouse itself, Costco’s food court is beloved for fast food that’s budget-friendly, delicious, and absolutely ginormous. And while Costco’s infamous hot dog combo and $1.99 pizza slice are iconic orders, the most underrated food court find is the Costco Chicken Bake.
We’ve always been fans of the Costco Chicken Bake, and our test kitchens even recreated the classic with a copycat recipe. However, nothing tastes as good as a Chicken Bake straight from the food court—and we have a couple of theories as to why. It’s not just the price tag.
There’s a surprising connection between this item and Costco’s highly debated, forever-cherished pizza.
What Makes Costco’s Chicken Bake So Good?
If you’re a Chicken Bake newbie, the sandwich is a food court MVP for its combination of flavors, textures, and affordability. Similar to a calzone or Hot Pockets-style item, the Chicken Bake features a flaky crust stuffed with diced chicken, cheese, bacon, and creamy Caesar dressing, and it’s served hot as a true comfort food.
Dotdash Meredith Food Studios
At $3.99, you can’t beat the price—especially considering its size and the amount of filling. Similar to a Subway Footlong, the substantial menu item could be shared as two meals for under $2 a serving. But the real deal on this chicken sandwich is just how good it tastes, which can be attributed to a few factors.
The handheld dough pocket features a cheese blend of mozzarella, provolone, and Parmesan, which adds a layer of richness—especially since more cheese is melted into the crispy bread surrounding the filling. One fan on Reddit said it best: It’s “a damn good sammich.”
The crust—crispy and flaky on the outside, soft and doughy on the inside—is a key element of the Chicken Bake’s success. Costco connoisseurs know that the food court’s pizza crust consistently delivers a fluffy interior with a crispy finish. And it turns out that Costco uses the same beloved crust recipe for the Chicken Bake. This contrast in texture, combined with the tender chicken, melted cheese, and slight zing from the Caesar dressing, makes each bite so satisfying.
The Chicken Bake is a quick, convenient option, especially for those already shopping at Costco, but if you aren’t in the mood to stop at the food court or already have your sights set on a hot dog combo, the Chicken Bake is also available in the frozen section. Some fans on Reddit even claim it’s better than the food court original.
“I actually enjoy the frozen ones more,” said one Redditor. “Feels like it has a bit more flavor and saucier. Sometimes feel like the food court ones need a sauce to accompany it.”
The frozen version is sold in 6-count packages with individually wrapped sandwiches for around $15. And each flaky pocket is easily microwaveable for a quick bite. Just like the food court offering, Kirkland Signature Chicken Bakes features chicken, mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan, smoky bacon, and creamy Caesar dressing—all in a flaky and crispy crust.
According to Costco’s website, the frozen version follows the same food court recipe. However, there’s one main difference: The frozen sandwich still contains green onions. It’s an ingredient you won’t find in the current food court version, and a subject often debated on Reddit.
Regardless of whether you’re buying the frozen version or heading straight to the food court, a Chicken Bake is one of the highlights of a Costco shopping experience. And if you’re stocking up in the freezer section, you might as well grab some other Kirkland Signature fan favorites to round out your list.
